Friday, November 30, 2007

Attorney Fees & Assessment Enforcement

Question: " I am late paying my assessments. I received a letter from my HOA's Attorney stating that my assessments are delinquent and charging me attorney's fees. Can they do this?"

Yes, they can recover attorney fees. Civil Code § 1366(e) states that an association may recover the following when an assessment becomes delinquent:

(1) Reasonable costs incurred in collecting the delinquent assessment, including reasonable attorney's fees.


(2) A late charge not exceeding 10 percent of the delinquent assessment or ten dollars ($10), whichever is greater, unless the declaration specifies a late charge in a smaller amount, in which case any late charge imposed shall not exceed the amount specified in the declaration.


(3) Interest on all sums imposed in accordance with this section, including the delinquent assessments, reasonable fees and costs of collection, and reasonable attorney's fees, at an annual interest rate not to exceed 12 percent, commencing 30 days after the assessment becomes due, unless the declaration specifies the recovery of interest at a rate of a lesser amount, in which case the lesser rate of interest shall apply.

Note: The information contained is not legal advice and does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Contact us via email Ryan.McClure.Esq@gmail.com or call us at 951.818.0687.

Monday, November 26, 2007

Failure to Enforce HOA Restrictive Covenants

Question; " We as a Board have had a history of non-enforcement of our CC&R's. How does this affect future enforcement?"

Many Boards face this very issue. Many Board members inherit a history of non-compliance and then are presented with the situation of whether they will enforce the Declarations restrictive covenants against members of the community. A Board has a duty to enforce the restrictions listed in the community Declaration and thus must not enforce the restrictions in a arbitrary or capricious manner. However, if the Board has no history of enforcement and tries enforcing a restriction or imposing a fine against a member the member will have several available defenses to mount against the Board, which may result in the Board either acquiescing to the members non-compliance based on Board inaction or the Board may lose if the issue is presented to a third party neutral like a Mediator or Arbitrator.

Therefore, it is important for the Board to be constantly diligent in enforcing the community covenants and when presented with a history of inaction the Board needs to recognize that future enforcement may provoke defenses by community members that maybe successful. In addition, it is important that the Board not to appear to enforce the restrictions arbitrarily so all members should be treated the same.

Note: The information contained is not legal advice and does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Contact us via email Ryan.McClure.Esq@gmail.com or call us at 951.818.0687.

Thursday, November 22, 2007

The Davis- Stirling Act

Question: " What is the Davis-Stirling Act? My HOA talks about it all the time and I am not sure what they are talking about?"

The Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act came to life in 1985 and encompasses Civil Code Sections 1350 to 1376. It is a set of statutory laws that form the basis for the creation, operation, and regulation of common interest developments or HOA's in California. The Davis-Stirling Act only applies to communities where membership is mandatory.

Note: The information contained is not legal advice and does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Contact us via email Ryan.McClure.Esq@gmail.com or call us at 951.818.0687.

Wednesday, November 21, 2007

Business and Professions Code § 11505

Business and Professions Code § 11505 is a very important code section for common interest development managers, the companies that employ these managers, and the community associations (HOA) that hire these managers.

B & P § 11505 states that it is a unfair business practice for a common interest development manager, a company that either hires a manager, or a company that has a financial interest in a company that hires a manager to perform any of the following on or after July 1, 2003:

  • To use the title or hold oneself out as a common interest development manager, or use any term that may suggest that they are holding this position without first meeting the requirement of B&P § 11502 (requirements to be called common interest development manager) ; or
  • To state or advertise to another that they are certified, registered or licensed to perform the job functions of a common interest development manager; or
  • To state or advertise a license number, unless the license number is specified by statute, regulation, or ordinance; or
  • To fail to disclose or misrepresent any of the items listed in B&P § 11504, which requires a person who either does perform or endeavors to perform the functions of a common interest development manager to disclose to the community association board the following; 1)whether the person has met the requirements under B&P § 11502, which would allow them to be called a certified common interest development manager, 2)The name, address, and telephone number of the professional association that certified the common interest development manager,the date the manager was certified, and the status of the certification, 3) the location of their office, 4) prior to entering into a contract with with association, the manager must disclose to the board as to whether the manager or its employer's fidelity insurance covers operating and reserve funds. However, it appears that this subsection does not require either party to carry such insurance, and finally 5) whether manager has an active real estate license.

Note: The information contained is not legal advice and does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Contact us via email Ryan.McClure.Esq@gmail.com or call us at 951.818.0687.

Tuesday, November 20, 2007

Stand Up and Be Heard!

Question: " Can HOA members stand up and talk during the board meetings, and how much time do I have to talk?"

Yes, members of the association do have a right to speak at scheduled board meetings and the board is responsible for setting the time in which the members have to voice their opinion.

In accordance with Civil Code 1363.05, which is referred to as the Common Interest Development Open Meeting Act, states that any member of the association may attend a board meeting. Subsection (i) of the same code section provides that any association member may speak at the board meeting except for meetings held in executive session. The subsection goes on to state that the board will determine a "reasonable" time limit in which all members will be afforded.

Note: The information contained is not legal advice and does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Contact us via email Ryan.McClure.Esq@gmail.com or call us at 951.818.0687.

Monday, November 19, 2007

Association Board Meeting Minutes

Question: "Are we required as a Board to generate minutes of all the Board of Director meetings that we conduct? Also where do we keep the minutes after they have been recorded?"

Yes, the Board is required to generate minutes of regular scheduled meetings. Corp. Code § 8320 requires each corp to keep minutes of the proceedings of their members, board, and committees of the board. In fact, the Board meeting minutes must be produced and available for members within 30 days after the scheduled Board meeting. Meeting minutes must also be distributed to community members upon their request.

The Davis- Stirling Act (DSA) carves out an exception to the general rule when the Board meets in executive session. The DSA requires only that matters discussed during an executive session are "generally noted" in the subsequent Board meeting that is open to the general association membership.


Generally, the board will meet in executive session to discuss such matters as the discipline of a member of the community, contracts with outside vendors, and even upon the request of an individual member of the community.

On a practical note, the minutes may be kept in a minutes book, which can be obtained through various on-line and retail merchants. (http://www.corpkit.com/store/catalog/) Your association lawyer may be able to secure such a book as well. Corp. Code § 8320 requires that minutes and other record keeping books shall be kept in written form or any other form, which is capable of being converted into a legible tangible form.

Note: The information contained is not legal advice and does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Contact us via email Ryan.McClure.Esq@gmail.com or call us at 951.818.0687.

Sunday, November 18, 2007

3 Step Process to Dispute or Pay Delinquent Association Assessments

Question; " I have received notice that the association is going to put a lien on my property. I don't believe that the assessments are correct and I would like to dispute the assessments they are charging me. How do I dispute the assessments?"

Assuming that the owner of the separate interest receives a certified pre- notification of the lien in accordance with Civil Code 1367.1 the owner that is now on notice has the following options on disputing the assessments that could possibly preclude foreclosure by the association:



  1. The owner may submit a written request to participate in the associations documented payment plan to bring all past due assessments current. This option assumes that the association has a documented payment plan.

  2. The owner of the property may submit a written request to resolve the dispute through the associations "Meet and Confer" program.

  3. The owner may wish to submit the assessment dispute to a form of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR).

Homeowners Association (HOA) Attorney

Note: The information contained is not legal advice and does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Contact us via email Ryan.McClure.Esq@gmail.com or call us at 951.818.0687.

Friday, November 16, 2007

Delinquent Assessments

Question; "When are my assessments considered late? If my assessments are late what can the HOA do to me? Can they foreclose on my home?"

The short answer is that your assessments will be considered late if not paid within 15 days after they are due. However, the declaration of the community might extend this period so homeowners should consult their governing documents first. Yes, an association may foreclose on a owners home if certain requirements are first met (see highlighted statement below).

Pursuant to Civil Code 1365.1(b) the association shall distribute the following written statement in 12-point type to every member of the association within the 60-day period prior to the associations fiscal year. This statement outlines the relevant law as it relates to late assessments, foreclosure, and collection of assessments and that is why I have included the entire statement.



(b) The notice required by this section shall read as follows:

"NOTICE ASSESSMENTS AND FORECLOSURE
This notice outlines some of the rights and responsibilities of owners of property in common interest developments and the associations that manage them. Please refer to the sections of the Civil Code indicated for further information. A portion of the information in this notice applies only to liens recorded on or after January 1, 2003. You may wish to consult a lawyer if you dispute an assessment.

ASSESSMENTS AND FORECLOSURE
Assessments become delinquent 15 days after they are due, unless the governing documents provide for a longer time. The failure to pay association assessments may result in the loss of an owner's property through foreclosure. Foreclosure may occur either as a result of a court action, known as judicial foreclosure or without court action, often referred to as nonjudicial foreclosure. For liens recorded on and after January 1, 2006, an association may not use judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure to enforce that lien if the amount of the delinquent assessments or dues, exclusive of any accelerated assessments, late charges, fees, attorney's fees, interest, and costs of collection, is less than one thousand eight hundred dollars ($1,800). For delinquent assessments or dues in excess of one thousand eight hundred dollars ($1,800) or more than 12 months delinquent, an association may use judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure subject to the conditions set forth in Section 1367.4 of the Civil Code. When using judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure, the association records a lien on the owner's property. The owner's property may be sold to satisfy the lien if the amounts secured by the lien are not paid. (Sections 1366, 1367.1, and 1367.4 of the Civil Code)

In a judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure, the association may recover assessments, reasonable costs of collection, reasonable attorney's fees, late charges, and interest. The association may not use nonjudicial foreclosure to collect fines or penalties, except for costs to repair common areas damaged by a member or a member's guests, if the governing documents provide for this. (Sections 1366 and 1367.1 of the Civil Code)

The association must comply with the requirements of Section 1367.1 of the Civil Code when collecting delinquent assessments. If the association fails to follow these requirements, it may not record a lien on the owner's property until it has satisfied those requirements. Any additional costs that result from satisfying the requirements are the responsibility of the association. (Section 1367.1 of the Civil Code)

At least 30 days prior to recording a lien on an owner's separate interest, the association must provide the owner of record with certain documents by certified mail, including a description of its collection and lien enforcement procedures and the method of calculating the amount. It must also provide an itemized statement of the charges owed by the owner. An owner has a right to review the association's records to verify the debt. (Section 1367.1 of the Civil Code)
If a lien is recorded against an owner's property in error, the person who recorded the lien is required to record a lien release within 21 days, and to provide an owner certain documents in this regard. (Section 1367.1 of the Civil Code)

The collection practices of the association may be governed by state and federal laws regarding fair debt collection. Penalties can be imposed for debt collection practices that violate these laws.

PAYMENTS
When an owner makes a payment, he or she may request a receipt, and the association is required to provide it. On the receipt, the association must indicate the date of payment and the person who received it. The association must inform owners of a mailing address for overnight payments. (Section 1367.1 of the Civil Code)

An owner may dispute an assessment debt by submitting a written request for dispute resolution to the association as set forth in Article 5 (commencing with Section 1368.810) of Chapter 4 of Title 6 of Division 2 of the Civil Code. In addition, an association may not initiate a foreclosure without participating in alternative dispute resolution with a neutral third party as set forth in Article 2 (commencing with Section 1369.510) of Chapter 7 of Title 6 of Division 2 of the Civil Code, if so requested by the owner. Binding arbitration shall not be available if the association intends to initiate a judicial foreclosure.

An owner is not liable for charges, interest, and costs of collection, if it is established that the assessment was paid properly on time. (Section 1367.1 of the Civil Code)

MEETINGS AND PAYMENT PLANS
An owner of a separate interest that is not a timeshare may request the association to consider a payment plan to satisfy a delinquent assessment. The association must inform owners of the standards for payment plans, if any exist. (Section 1367.1 of the Civil Code)
The board of directors must meet with an owner who makes a proper written request for a meeting to discuss a payment plan when the owner has received a notice of a delinquent assessment. These payment plans must conform with the payment plan standards of the association, if they exist.

Absent a contrary provision in the Declaration that provides a longer time period both special and regular assessments are delinquent if not paid within 15 days after the due date. If the assessment is delinquent the association may recover the following under Civil Code 1366(e):

(1) Reasonable costs incurred in collecting the delinquent assessment, including reasonable attorney's fees.

(2) A late charge not exceeding 10 percent of the delinquent assessment or ten dollars ($10), whichever is greater, unless the declaration specifies a late charge in a smaller amount, in which case any late charge imposed shall not exceed the amount specified in the declaration.

(3) Interest on all sums imposed in accordance with this section, including the delinquent assessments, reasonable fees and costs of collection, and reasonable attorney's fees, at an annual interest rate not to exceed 12 percent, commencing 30 days after the assessment becomes due, unless the declaration specifies the recovery of interest at a rate of a lesser amount, in which case the lesser rate of interest shall apply.

In the event that there assessments become delinquent the Association may elect to either 1) impose a lien on delinquent owners separate interest or the association may 2) collect the past due assessments by way of collection. It is important to note that if the association decides to place a lien on the owners separate interest the lien can be used to foreclose on the owners property.

Homeowners Association (HOA) Attorney
Note: The information contained is not legal advice and does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Contact us via email Ryan.McClure.Esq@gmail.com or call us at 951.818.0687.















Thursday, November 15, 2007

Low Watering Plants and Artifical Grass

Question: " Does Artificial grass qualify as a Low Watering Plant?"

No, I don't believe that the spirit or intent of Civil Code 1353.8, which precludes a Common Interest Development (CID) from promulgating rules that have the effect of prohibiting the use of low water-using plants as a group was intended to cover artificial grass. First, it is not a plant... it is plastic. Second, the artificial grass does not require water. Therefore, the plain language of the statute seems to be very clear in that a HOA's architectural guidelines shall not prohibit the use of low water-using plants, which would arguably not include artificial grass.

Well then, what plants do constitute low water-using plants as a group? The statute doesn't guide us on this issue nor does it provide an Architectural committee a basis of denying or approving the type of plants that would qualify. I think it would be advisable for a Architectural committee to perform some research as to what types of plants would qualify as low-water using plants for the region in which the community is located. Select a variety of these qualified plants and establish them as community approved low-water using plants. This approach may cut off and avoid an action on the part of a member claiming arbitrary and capricious application of the architectural rules and violation of 1353.8.

Note: The information contained is not legal advice and does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Contact us via email Ryan.McClure.Esq@gmail.com or call us at 951.818.0687.

Monday, November 12, 2007

HOA's and Daycare Centers

Question: " I bought a condo and didn't realize there was a daycare operating next door. Why doesn't the Board of my HOA shut it down?"

Health & S C § 1597.40 (c) provides that restrictions placed on homeowners within a Common Interest Development (CID) that prohibit the operation of a daycare are void. Health & S C § 1596.78 defines a Family Daycare Home as one that provides care & supervision to 14 or less children in the caregivers home for not more than 24 hours and is either a Large Family Daycare facility or Small Daycare facility.


  • Large Family Daycare center; 7-14 children in the caregivers residence, which includes children under 10 that reside at the caregivers residence.
  • Small Family Daycare center; 8 or fewer children, which includes children under 10 that reside at the caregivers residence.

Although a HOA may not preclude the operation of a daycare within its community by language in the Declaration the Association or its members may still be able to bring a nuisance action against the resident owners of the daycare facility for harmful or dangerous conduct. The HOA may also require the daycare provider to have proper insurance (see below), proper local and state law licensing, and ensure compliance with community rules.

In addition, Health and Safety Code §1597.531 requires a daycare provider to elect between the following options as it relates to liability coverage;

  1. Carry Liability insurance covering injury to guests & clients of at least $100k per occurrence & $300K in total; or

  2. A $300K Bond; or

  3. The daycare can elect to not carry either of the two foregoing options and elect to create a file that contains affidavits that are signed by the parents that have children at the daycare informing the parents that the daycare does not carry insurance or a bond. (addtl requirements are required for the affidavit if the daycare provider is not the homeowner)

Finally, Health and Safety Code §1597.531(b) states that if the daycare provider elects either the insurance coverage or the bond then the policy must name the HOA or the owner of the property as an additional insured party if "all" of the following requirements are met;

  1. The HOA Board or property owner makes a written request to be added to the policy.

  2. Adding the HOA or property owner will not result in cancellation or non-renewal of the policy or bond.

  3. Any additional premiums as result of adding the HOA or owners are paid by the owner or HOA.

In addition to the above requirements there may be public policy arguments why a small business should be allowed to operate within a HOA community. I plan on covering this topic in future posts.

Note: The information contained is not legal advice and does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Contact us via email Ryan.McClure.Esq@gmail.com or call us at 951.818.0687.

HOA Common Area & Exclusive Common Area

I received the following question; "I live in a Condo in CA and it is run by a HOA. They mention common area's a lot, but I am not sure what they mean by Common Area..."

COMMON AREA

The Davis Sterling Act defines a Common Area as "the entire common interest development except the separate interest...". CC § 1351(b). The statute defines a separate interest in a condo community as the individual unit. The separate interest in a condo would be the condo unit itself. " Generally, the common area's are owned by either the members of the community or the Association. Many condos share roofs and walls which could be considered common area's. In addition, shared driveways, hallways, parking lots, and recreational area's could also all be considered a common area. You can assume that everything but the owners separate interest may be viewed as a common area. Absent language in the Declaration stating otherwise the Association is responsible for the upkeep, maintenance, and repairing of the common areas within a community.

Exclusive Use Common Area

The statute goes on to define a Exclusive Use Common Area as;

(i) "Exclusive use common area" means a portion of the common areas designated by the declaration for the exclusive use of one or more, but fewer than all, of the owners of the separate interests and which is or will be appurtenant to the separate interest or interests.

(1) Unless the declaration otherwise provides, any shutters, awnings, window boxes, doorsteps, stoops, porches, balconies, patios, exterior doors, door frames, and hardware incident thereto, screens and windows or other fixtures designed to serve a single separate interest, but located outside the boundaries of the separate interest, are exclusive use common areas allocated exclusively to that separate interest.

(2) Notwithstanding the provisions of the declaration, internal and external telephone wiring designed to serve a single separate interest, but located outside the boundaries of the separate interest, are exclusive use common areas allocated exclusively to that separate interest.

Absent a provision in the Declaration the separate interest property owner is responsible for the maintenance of the Exclusive Use Common Areas.

Note: The information contained is not legal advice and does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Contact us via email Ryan.McClure.Esq@gmail.com or call us at 951.818.0687.